In Parshat Vayetze, we see Jacob engaged in the primary business of the biblical patriarchs: shepherding. Whenever I read of shepherding in the Torah, I am reminded of my limited experience accompanying Palestinian shepherds in the same part of the Land of Israel through which Jacob journeys at the beginning of our parshah. About a decade ago, as a recent college graduate and prospective rabbinical student studying Torah in Jerusalem, through T’ruah and other organizations, I participated in protective presence activism in the West Bank. This effort was profoundly similar to the recent Protect the Harvest campaign through which T’ruah helped coordinate rabbis and volunteers to accompany Palestinians to harvest their olives, with the goal of dissuading violence and intimidation from Israeli settlers or soldiers. Harvesting olives or walking with sheep through the West Bank is often a profoundly awe-inspiring experience, and a form of religious practice that we can connect to the story of Jacob in our parshah.
The natural landscape of Israel and Palestine is remarkable, and shepherding requires one to slow down enough to be able to appreciate this natural splendor — I can certainly understand why Jacob exclaimed, “How awe-inspiring is this place?!” (Genesis 28:17) However, at the same time, the cynical, violent, and dominating behavior of many Israeli Jews designed to make Palestinian life unbearable and drive people from their homes is horrifying and heartbreaking. In recent years, extremist settler groups have increasingly built shepherding outposts and used the pretext of bringing their flock to pasture in order to storm into Palestinian communities, sometimes cutting off water pipes and other basic utilities.
Find more resources on Vayetze.
This callous and cruel approach to shepherding could not be in more stark contrast with the way of shepherding that is celebrated by ancient rabbinic tradition. In Shemot Rabbah, the rabbis wonder what qualified Moses to become the shepherd of the people of Israel, and conclude that it was because of the tender, compassionate care he showed even for a small lamb who wandered thirstily away from the flock. Through this Midrash, our sages, of blessed memory, teach us that in order for Moses to be capable of leading the Jewish people, it was not enough that he be impatient with injustice and quick to take action, as we see in the story of his intervention in the beating of a Hebrew slave. To be capable of the leadership the Jewish people needed, Moses needed not only an intolerance of injustice but also a disposition of patience and compassion.
Protective Presence activism requires both moral clarity and a calm, compassionate, patient approach, even and especially when confronted with people who are angry and provocative. Maintaining a compassionate, peaceful demeanor when face-to-face with anger or vitriol is not an easy thing to do, but rabbis and cantors are particularly well-suited for this work. After all, as Jewish communal leaders, we are tasked with tending compassionately to people as they experience many of the most difficult and upsetting moments in life. Not infrequently, we are responsible for supporting people who hold very different views than our own on questions of great moral urgency for the Jewish people and the world. By maintaining such a calm and compassionate presence, we tend to our communities, and even when we are not able to actually prevent a violent or tragic incident, we can contribute to de-escalation and peacebuilding. Whether in the West Bank or at a local polling place during the U.S. elections where T’ruah rabbis and cantors served as poll chaplains in partnership with Faiths United to Save Democracy, we bring the compassionate and attentive leadership modeled by Moses into places where people need us to show up.
Find more resources on Israel and Palestine.
Yet, there are times when rather than patience, decisive action is called for, as we see with Jacob in our parshah. In Genesis 31:2, Jacob sees that Lavan’s attitude toward him has changed for the worse, “Behold, Yaakov saw that the face of Lavan was not with him as it had been yesterday, or the day before.” Recognizing the subtle signs of a threatening expression, Jacob takes decisive action to save his family from conflict. This too is required of us when we engage in protective presence, and echoes with the training many congregational leaders receive about synagogue security. While we must greet everyone with compassion, we must also pay close attention to signs that we may need to take protective action and de-escalate a situation.
Of course, patience has its limits, and too much patience with wicked or harmful behavior can cut us off from connection with the Divine. Midrash Tanchuma communicates this insight in the voice of God in a teaching brought by Rashi on 31:3: “As long as you are close with this corrupt person, my Shekhinah will not be present with you.” When we are too tolerant and too close to unethical behavior, even if we are not the perpetrators, this can leave a stain on our souls. So, from my reflection on our parshah, I have a newfound appreciation of just how challenging the sacred work that members and supporters of T’ruah strive to do as Jewish moral voices is. At the very same time we work to bring compassionate and peaceful presence into zones of conflict, we must keep our eyes open to true threats. We must not tolerate injustice or allow ourselves to become accustomed to the corrosive behavior and attitudes spreading within our people. We must be willing to show up, to protect those under threat, and to speak clearly when our own communities are complicit. And through it all, we must strive to remain shepherds of the people of Israel, with compassion and care for all.
Rabbi Micah R. Friedman (he/him) is a rabbi, Jewish educator, and scholar who lives in Ithaca, New York, with his spouse, Rabbi Talia Laster. He serves part-time as rabbi of Temple Israel of Vestal, New York, a modern, egalitarian synagogue, and designs Jewish learning experiences that weave together Torah, rabbinic literature, and contemporary questions in ways that are both accessible and intellectually rigorous.
