Towards the end of Parshat Toldot, we find Jacob and Esau in an existential battle of dominance. Now, Esau harbored a grudge against Jacob because of the blessing that his father had given him, and Esau said to himself, “Let but the mourning period of my father come, and I will kill my brother Jacob.” (Genesis 27:41) Jacob had bested his brother Esau, and in so doing built on their enmity towards each other to a peak. Not only had he won, but his victory was one that echoed a previous battle between the brothers, in which Jacob outsmarted Esau and convinced him to give Jacob his birthright.
Their hatred of each other couldn’t be more plain. In Genesis 27:37, Isaac says to his son Esau, “I have made [Jacob] master over you: I have given all his brothers for servants.” Jacob, who was perceived as the younger and therefore less deserving, is now his brother’s master. The rabbis don’t see that as simply a familial battle, but as the foundation of battles that happen between nations. According to midrash, Esau takes the allegorical role as the ancestor of the Romans who later destroy the Second Temple in Jerusalem and our expulsion from the land of Israel. “Two prides of their nations are in your womb — [Roman Emperor] Hadrian amongst the gentiles and Solomon amongst the Israelites.” (Genesis Rabbah 63:7)
But while they are stand-ins for greater nations, it is important to remember that these are still brothers, meaning that they have shared a significant upbringing together with deeply intertwined identities. Part of why their battle feels so fraught is precisely because of their closeness.
Find more resources on Toldot.
According to a quote often attributed to Mark Twain, history doesn’t repeat itself, but it rhymes. We find ourselves in the wake of a historic election in the United States, with the potential to set the course for the Democratic Party, if only it knows how to utilize its success. The Democratic Party is deeply divided right now, with multiple factions vying for leadership from the Democratic Socialist of America block to the center-left block. This country’s path towards a more progressive and kinder future is dependent on the party’s ability to recognize its shared values and history.
When I flew to Minneapolis last January as part of a clergy call to show up for those most impacted by ICE, I saw democracy in action. It didn’t look like a ballot box. It looked like neighbors with each other’s numbers on speed dial, ready to respond when ICE knocked on their doors. Where social media and polarization have sowed distrust across much of the country, people in Minneapolis showed up for each other and recognized that we can only succeed when we work together.
There is a deep sense of distrust across the country, as people believe that their country is being stolen from them by forces that they do not understand. The Radak, in reference to Jacob stealing Esau’s birthright, says that “there is no greater craftiness than to exploit one’s brother’s hunger and fatigue and to buy his birthright for a dish of lentils.” (Radak on Breishit 27:36:3)
Find more resources on democracy.
People are angry; they feel exploited. The Radak’s commentary contains within it the secret to our continued success. The Radak reminds us that while we battle together for progressive causes, we must keep in mind that it is our neighbor we are arguing for, not against. Wherever we stand politically, our stories are connected, and therefore our success is dependent on seeing each other as all connected.
We can steer the way toward this sense of communal care. It starts by recognizing the pain of isolation that we all share. It continues by naming that we all deserve a future of dignity, affordability, and health. We each have the right to lentils, without the fear of being exploited for them.
And so we look forward to a newfound sense of power. It will be an uphill battle to change the tides of MAGA, especially as President Trump still holds the reins of the White House. But we can win. All we need is that we share a world together, and we are all family with a shared history. Ken y’hi ratzon. May it be so.
Cantor Gabriel Lehrman is a cantor at Temple Emanuel in Denver, where, in addition to cultivating spiritual life, he is helping to build interfaith coalitions towards a humane approach to immigration in Colorado. Supporting social justice has been a part of his spiritual work for years, focusing on the environment, Israel-Palestine, and affordability.
T’ruah: The Rabbinic Call for Human Rights is a 501(c)(3) and does not conduct partisan political activities in support of or in opposition to any political candidate.
